• Murder at Cherry Creek Saloon Interactive Mingle Murder Mystery Party Game

    Murder at Cherry Creek Saloon Interactive Mingle Murder Mystery Party Game

    It's 1857 and the California Gold Rush is just coming to an end. In the sleepy town of Cherry Creek, the saloon is the only source of entertainment for locals and those passing through en route to San Fransisco. Suddenly, a saloon brawl breaks out, and when the dust settles, one man is dead. Who killed him, and what became of the sac he wore on his belt?

  • Murder at the Winery Murder Mystery Party Game – Gateway

    Murder at the Winery Murder Mystery Party Game – Gateway

    In a remote area of Italy, high above a hill, sits Girato Nel Buio Winery. To celebrate their third year releasing the special vintage "Organo", they are holding a tasting, to which some of the industry's elite have been invited. But just before the tasting can commence, a man is found murdered in the cellars! Who killed him and why? Things, and people, are not who they seem!

  • The Sly Mr. Foxx Interactive Mingle Murder Mystery Party Game  – Gateway!

    The Sly Mr. Foxx Interactive Mingle Murder Mystery Party Game – Gateway!

    A Great Gatsby-esque murder mystery party set in a mansion in the Roaring 20's. Find out who killed Dahlia Sparrow, but also the identity of The Sly Mr. Foxx and his mysterious reasons for inviting such a strange mix of people to his private party this evening!

  • Murder at Mardi Gras Mystery Game – Gateway!

    Murder at Mardi Gras Mystery Game – Gateway!

    The year is 1899 in New Orleans, and Mardi Gras celebrations are underway. Parade floats fill the streets and each evening, various Krewes throw lavish masked balls. You’re invited to the Calypso Ball, the inaugural […]

  • Salem Witches Murder Mystery Game – Gateway!

    Salem Witches Murder Mystery Game – Gateway!

    The year is 1692, and the residents of Salem Town are panicked. Accusations of witchcraft are flying, and even the most pious men and women are being accused, imprisoned and, if they don’t confess, […]

  • The Phantom of the Auction House – Gateway!

    The Phantom of the Auction House – Gateway!

    The perfect mystery for any party! Two mysteries to solve - the identity of the killer and the mystery of the enigmatic Phantom!

  • The Halloween Party Murder Mystery Game – Gateway!

    The Halloween Party Murder Mystery Game – Gateway!

    Witches are cackling, Bats are flying by, It’s bound to be a wild night, ‘Cause someone’s gonna die... A not-so-clean murder mystery party set at a Halloween Party perfect for... well, a Halloween Party, of course!

  • Vampires vs. Werewolves Mystery Party – Gateway!

    Vampires vs. Werewolves Mystery Party – Gateway!

    Vampires and werewolves face off once again! The peace treaty is broken when word comes of a vampire/werewolf hybrid that has been sommoned to the area by one of the suspects. as it vampire of werewolf who summoned it, and why would they break the treaty after 50 years of peace? A compelling non-murder mystery with an open setting, designed to fit your party, wherever you hold it!

  • The Pirates Revenge Murder Mystery Party – Gateway!

    The Pirates Revenge Murder Mystery Party – Gateway!

    The captain has been found murdered in his quarters. Suddenly, the pirate crew are suspects. Everyone is, by definition, a scoundrel, but which one of these salty dogs actually killed the captain?

  • Murder at the Superhero Peace Convention Mystery Party – Gateway!

    Murder at the Superhero Peace Convention Mystery Party – Gateway!

    A murder mystery with characters inspired by superhero and villain favourites! The worst supervillain the world has ever seen has announced his retirement, but is found dead at the Peace Convention! Who killed him, why and how?

  • The Masquerade Murder Mystery Party Game – Gateway

    The Masquerade Murder Mystery Party Game – Gateway

    The Da Vinci Code of murder mystery parties! Set in St. Mark's Library in Venice and available in co-ed or all-female versions, determine why the librarian was murdered, what it has to do with the real-life Antikythera Mechanism, and whether the "key" to decoding the device is just a myth!

  • A Flapper Murder at the 1920’s Speakeasy! Murder Mystery Party Game – Gateway

    A Flapper Murder at the 1920’s Speakeasy! Murder Mystery Party Game – Gateway

    Take a trip back in time to the Roaring 20's - a time of flappers, gangsters, prohibition and speakeasies. Solve the mystery of who killed Fanny Birchwood in either the co-ed or all-female version of our best-selling murder mystery party game!

Looking for an easy, hassle-free murder mystery game to suit your unique party?

Isn’t it Frustrating to find the perfect mystery theme, only to discover it only allows for 8 guests, when 12 will be attending your party? How disappointing to have to abandon the theme you want because the mystery party company doesn’t offer a version for your number of guests. That’s why we offer a number of variations to our mysteries, and if we don’t have the one you need, we can usually create the version you need. We think it’s time that a mystery party company started offering you what you need.

Why Choose Shot In The Dark Mysteries?

The Original Mingle Mystery Investigation

No scripts, rounds or silly stunts; a genuine investigation that gets your guests sleuthing as a detective would, searching for the person who had the motive, means and opportunity to commit the murder.

The Host Can Be A Suspect

We hosts work hard to throw parties, and we believe that you, as the host, should be able to take on a suspect role f you choose and solve the mystery as well. You should get to have just as much fun as your guests!

The Best Customer Service

This is not just some hobby we do in our spare time. Mystery parties are ALL we do – we eat, sleep and breathe this company, and we pride ourselves on being here to serve our clients worldwide through email and live chat.
Intro_Video
party-planning

Party Planning Checklist!

Sign up for our Party Planning Tips email and INSTANTLY receive a FREE 46 page party planning checklist you can use for ANY type of party you host!



We never share info. We’re selfish like that.