Optionals | Shot In The Dark Mysteries Murder Mystery Games

Murder on the Continental Express Murder Mystery Party Game Optional Witness Pack 1 Female 1 Male
Optionals

Murder on the Continental Express Murder Mystery Party Game Optional Witness Pack 1 Female 1 Male

Need an optional Witness pack for unexpected guests and not-sures? You can add a two optional witness expansion pack while checking out.

Chev2021-01-04T19:04:12+00:00

Haunted Island Murder Mystery Party Game Optional Witness Pack 1 Female 1 Male
Optionals

Haunted Island Murder Mystery Party Game Optional Witness Pack 1 Female 1 Male

Need an optional Witness pack for unexpected guests and not-sures? You can add a two optional witness expansion pack while checking out.

Chev2021-01-04T18:40:30+00:00

1950s Murder Mystery Party Game Optional Witness Pack 1 Female 1 Male
Optionals

1950s Murder Mystery Party Game Optional Witness Pack 1 Female 1 Male

Need an optional Witness pack for unexpected guests and not-sures? You can add a two optional witness expansion pack while checking out.

Chev2021-01-04T19:06:36+00:00

The Winter Wonderland All Female Optional Witness Pack 2 Females
Optionals

The Winter Wonderland All Female Optional Witness Pack 2 Females

Need an optional Witness pack for unexpected guests and not-sures? You can add a two optional witness expansion pack while checking out.

Chev2021-02-01T16:11:19+00:00

The Winter Wonderland Optional Witness Pack 1 Female 1 Male
Optionals

The Winter Wonderland Optional Witness Pack 1 Female 1 Male

Need an optional Witness pack for unexpected guests and not-sures? You can add a two optional witness expansion pack while checking out.

Chev2021-02-01T16:10:55+00:00

Wizards Optional Witness Pack 1 Female 1 Male
Optionals

Wizards Optional Witness Pack 1 Female 1 Male

Need an optional Witness pack for unexpected guests and not-sures? You can add a two optional witness expansion pack while checking out.

Chev2021-01-04T18:41:14+00:00

Murder at Studio Paradise Optional Witness Pack 1 Female 1 Male
Optionals

Murder at Studio Paradise Optional Witness Pack 1 Female 1 Male

Need an optional Witness pack for unexpected guests and not-sures? You can add a two optional witness expansion pack while checking out.

Chev2021-01-04T19:11:44+00:00

Mystery in Wonderland Optional Witness Pack 1 Female 1 Male
Optionals

Mystery in Wonderland Optional Witness Pack 1 Female 1 Male

Need an optional Witness pack for unexpected guests and not-sures? You can add a two optional witness expansion pack while checking out.

Chev2021-01-04T18:59:37+00:00

Murder at the Winery All Female Optional Witness Pack 2 Females
Optionals

Murder at the Winery All Female Optional Witness Pack 2 Females

Need an optional Witness pack for unexpected guests and not-sures? You can add a two optional witness expansion pack while checking out.

Chev2021-01-04T19:07:19+00:00

Murder at the Winery Optional Witness Pack 1 Female 1 Male
Optionals

Murder at the Winery Optional Witness Pack 1 Female 1 Male

Need an optional Witness pack for unexpected guests and not-sures? You can add a two optional witness expansion pack while checking out.

Chev2021-01-04T19:07:19+00:00

12 Next

Can’t find a match?

No gender mix to suit your guest list? With enough notice before your party, we can usually create the version you need. Contact us below and let us know how many male and female guests will be at your party, and the date of your party and we will email you back within 24 hours (often much less!) to discuss your party. (18 suspect max)

Request Customisation

This is the second year we’ve purchased a mystery for my daughter’s birthday party. The package and information last year made hosting it so easy and the girls had an absolute blast. – Aimee

It was OFF THE HOOK FUN!!! Thank you SO much!!! – Mimi

I would like to thank and congratulate you on such fantastic customer service. – Emma

My friends want to make this a yearly tradition. – Noelle

The Murder Mystery was the crowning glory. – Jo-Anne

Thank you so much! The level of customer service that I’ve received in placing this order has been outstanding. – Aimee

You are awesome and everyone on our team was amazed at the quality of the mystery. – Mimi

We had the best 16th birthday party for my daughter using the Murder at the Spa kit. – BJ

Everyone was laughing and enjoying themselves! – Jordan

You really helped create a memorable evening for our team! – Jordan

We’re looking forward to the next time! – Ilyssa

Your ingenuity was awesome! – Mariana

You’ll definitely be getting our business again. – Lauren

I can’t even begin to tell you how much fun we all had! – Amanda

I can’t wait to order another mystery. – Amanda

The party was a HUGE success. – Laurel

Can’t say enough about it!! – BJ

Outstanding customer service these days is rare. It is nice to find a company that truly cares about their customers and appreciates our business. – Aimee

Thank you for writing a creative and interesting mystery. – Jennifer

Thank you for a great product. – Nancy

I don’t know what I’m going to do to top this one. – Donna

Thank you thank you thank you! I have never enjoyed my own birthday so much! – Patricia

We had over 80 people there and everyone had a blast! – Renee

We had a blast, our friends loved it. – Jacob

Thank you for making my purchase and experience with Shot in the Dark Mysteries such a positive one. – Aimee

We and our guests had SO much fun playing our characters and trying to guess who did it. – Jennifer

No of Women
No of Men